Call for Abstracts for an edited collection of original and innovative essays. Mind Over Matter: Philosophical Essays on Self-Confidence and the Spiritual Dimension of Achievement
Edited by Roderick Nicholls and Heather
Salazar
Mind Over Matter aims to present an innovative, interdisciplinary, and rigorous philosophical analysis of the value of the self-confidence and the spiritual dimension of human achievement. Creative, scientific, artistic, intellectual and athletic achievements provide some of the diverse disciplines of achievement analyzed. The editors seek original philosophical contributions that challenge assumptions that productivity is wholly explicable through physical traits and the assertion of effort and instead show how faith, self-confidence and achievement can be ameliorated through mental and spiritual devotion or practice. Submit a 750 word abstract and brief CV to Rod Nicholls, editor of Philosophy & Religion, Brill/Rodopi
Value Inquiry Book Series at Rod_Nicholls@cbu.ca by January 15, 2020. Final papers should be 7,000 to 10,000 words in length and are due September 1, 2020.
Full Description
Editors are particularly interested in chapters on:
Scientific advancement, the context of invention, and paradigm shifts
Kant and the influence of spirituality on his thought
Empiricism and non-foundational epistemology
Mythology and narrative
Carl Jung's use of soul in psychological growth
Native American spirituality
Taoism
Sports psychology
African spirituality
Feminism
African American spirituality in the face of discrimination
Full Description
Countless scientists, artists, intellectuals,
religious or political leaders, and athletes have defied seemingly
unsurpassable limits of human achievement. To overcome the various obstacles
defining those limits, they must embody a tremendous confluence of powers that
have been cultivated through arduous preparation and training. Accompanying the
prolonged moments of achievement, however, is an equally tremendous consciousness
of peace – a feeling of ease and complete effortlessness. In break-through
accomplishments within a range of human activities, that is, human beings
exemplify a striking and somewhat paradoxical state of being in which exhilaration
and peace co-exist. This phenomenon deserves the careful attention of contemporary
philosophers.
First-hand, participant accounts still
tend to be articulated in quite traditional deist, pantheistic, or other
religious vocabulary, precisely because those perspectives are designed to
accommodate extraordinary experiences. Olympian Ryan Hall, for example, the
first US runner to break the one-hour record in a half-marathon, stated that when
participating in the activity he had trained for, he felt “easy” and “peaceful”
because “God [was] running with me.” In a different context, Plato argued that great
aesthetic achievements could not be explained simply by talent and skills (technê) but rather they were the result of
divine Eros taking possession of
human beings and using them as a means of expression. Einstein claimed that his
scientific inventiveness was inspired by, and dependent upon his wonder at the
universe conceived in the fashion of Spinoza’s God. In some Indian philosophy, to
give one more example, reaching the final stage of enlightenment is often
interpreted as a gift from God, a blessing that is impossible to achieve simply
through effort.
Yet the central phenomenon is not
necessarily religious in nature. At the turn of the 19th century,
for instance, Romanticism adapted traditional vocabulary to changing cultural circumstances.
This movement valorized the individuality of the literary, visual, or
performance artist, for example, because of the unique powers they manifested.
On the other hand, iconic figures such as Hölderlin or Blake or Nietzsche (in
certain moments) emphasized that certain people were an incarnation of impersonal
forces and hence they became a medium of some inspiring source which acted
through them involuntarily. Hence they continued to highlight the culminating
sense of being involved in the world while
at the same time detached from it. This
is the state which so intrigued Stanley Cavell when Thoreau claimed that
through a conscious effort one may eventually have the experience of “being
beside oneself in a sane sense” – an ecstatic experience of being a totally
immersed actor and completely impartial spectator. In European Romanticism or
American Transcendentalism, therefore, the process was a decidedly creative one,
but it culminated in a revelation of
what is “real’ or what is the case, simpliciter.
Regardless of whether the vocabulary is
religious or non-religious, however, opening these kind of discussions are likely
theoretical conversation stoppers for many philosophers (especially in the
analytic tradition) who will see frustratingly imprecise explanations which
presuppose the existence of an ultimately mysterious Reality. But rather than
dismiss the core insight regarding the relevant phenomenon out of hand, it
would be more productive to refocus and explore different ways of articulating
it. Consider, for instance that post-Kantian philosophy (in both the analytic
and continental traditions) has pursued the diverse ways in which human beings,
in some very real sense, contribute to and shape the world we inhabit. Wilfred
Sellars, to give just one example, argued that even color and shape of objects
were influenced systematically not just by psycho-physiological contributions
of the subject but by their beliefs and expectations. A straw coming up from a
clear glass of water, for instance, would be experienced by most people as
straight even though it should surely be perceived as bent by any objective
representation. While that might be a relatively trivial example, it does not
just suggest the extent to which an expansive web of beliefs, ideas and mental
habits shape our cognitive and emotional lives. It also opens the door to
examining how our lives can be profoundly reshaped
by adjusting existing practices or
adopting new ones.
For example, various instruments of
faith (including meditation, prayer, visualization, and even some personal
mantras and affirmations) just like recommendations of sports psychologists acted
upon by elite athletes are known to be efficacious. They demonstrate the
plausibility of the assumption that perceived limits of ordinary human
capacities can be transcended by concerted effort and focused belief. Though
the achievements of some people do appear to rely on the agent’s perception of
God’s will or some other metaphysically contested reality, it is reasonable to
suggest that breakthrough accomplishments depend on a deep inner confidence or
a sustained sense of knowing that existing
limits can be transcended. In a sense that must be systematically clarified, this
can tentatively be called faith in a non-religious sense. And more generally,
the commonly used phrase, “mind over matter” is a helpful ordinary language way
to start accounting for situations in which formidable physical limitations
are, often unexpectedly, overcome by the exercise of previously unknown mental
powers, untapped will-power, or other forms of faith-based power.
The latter terms are philosophically loaded, indeed. Yet using them
does not necessarily imply a commitment to some specific theoretical construal,
anymore than the phrase “mind over matter” depends on a certain position in the
philosophy of mind (dualism, idealism, etc.) Throughout his career, for
example, pragmatist philosopher and psychologist William James used similar
vocabulary to explore the idea that the lives of ordinary people were diminished not just by material need but by
deeply entrenched perceptions that spiritually limited them. Drawing on traditional
practices (of Indian Yogis and Christians like Loyola, for instance) and contemporary
scientific work (into hypnotism and automatism, for instance) he argued that reservoirs of energy that habitually are not tapped largely because
habitually people lack the practical knowledge to push through initial obstructions.
Psychiatrist and
holocaust survivor, Viktor Frankel, helped many people deal creatively with
suffering – from the horrific to the numbingly mundane – in order to cultivate
a sense of meaning and spiritual purpose without recourse to God. Multiple
incarnations of Dalai Lamas mediated through oppression and helped millions to
heal themselves and their relations through presence and compassion.
This collection aims to provide philosophical analyses of what can be
achieved through faith, confidence, and human will in a broadly spiritual sense
that does not rely on specific (or, in fact, any) religious doctrines or views.
Whether theistic, non-theistic, or atheistic, however, each chapter will focus
on a phenomenon which cannot be reduced to the physical or psychological, the
aesthetic or scientific, or to any binary opposition.
No comments:
Post a Comment